What's Better for EDC?: Minimalism or Redundancy

285 Likes
23 Comments
192 Shares

When it comes to everyday carry, there's no “one size fits all” approach. It holds true especially for one important question: just how much is too much? You might not have given it much thought, but you probably already have some idea of your preferences. Maybe you hate the feeling of too much stuff in your pockets and you like to travel light. Or you wouldn't step one foot out the door unless you had a few backups on you. You know, just in case. Each style has its merits, of course, and today we're going to take a more in-depth look at them to help you figure out which approach is best for your needs.

Less Is More

If you're new to everyday carry, chances are you'll start off with a carry most would consider on the minimal side. It might start with more common essentials like your phone, wallet, and keys. But from there, you might also carry a pen, a small flashlight, a small pocket knife, or a multi-tool with a knife built in.

12345678

In a minimal carry, you usually keep one item of each category, as opposed to carrying multiples or backups. Besides the actual number of items in the carry, a minimalist approach also applies to the design of those items as well. Think of clean, sleek designs, understated patterns, smaller sizes, and lighter weight.

With all these aspects combined, a minimalist carry offers some key benefits: it's lighter, easier to manage and access, and more comfortable to carry. If you're the type who can't stand feeling weighed down, it's better to go with a minimalist approach than to leave crucial gear behind entirely. Aesthetically, a minimalist carry might also be more appropriate if you're in an urban setting or office environment most of the time. Sometimes, being discreet is just as important as being functional when building a carry.

Of course, minimizing your carry means making sacrifices. You won't be able to have a tool for every job. And the tools you do have might not give you the best performance if they're smaller. For example, a keychain-sized knife might be able to make the cut, but it might take much longer or require a lot more effort than using a 4” folder would.

12345678

To pare down your carry to be more minimalist, experiment with removing gear you find you haven't used very often. Better yet, find a replacement, like a multi-tool, that consolidates those functions into something that's easier to carry. A keychain is a great place to start with this, especially since you can find a keychain-sized flashlight and pair it with a multi-functional keychain or tool.

Two is One, One is None

On the flip side, there's another school of thought: redundancy. You've probably heard the phrase “two is one, one is none” in some of the EDCs showcased on the site. It's the idea that in an emergency situation, it pays to have a backup to be truly prepared. If your primary tool fails, you'd be out of luck without a redundant item.

123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627

A more “maximalist” carry would fully embrace this idea, with one or more items dedicated to serving a specific function. In other words, it's all about covering your bases. That often includes a knife for cutting, a multi-tool for repairs, a flashlight, a fire source, and so on. Tools might be larger and more robust so they can handle tasks well outside of what your day-to-day might demand, just to be on the safe side. For example, a max'er might carry a full-sized 18650 flashlight with tons of power and epic runtimes.

With this approach, weight is less of a concern. Maximizing the overall functionality of your entire carry is the goal. If you agree with the idea that it's better to have and not need than to need and not have, this style of EDC is for you.

The obvious downside to having all this gear is all the bulk. It's almost like an art and a science to get the right balance of gear you need to feel prepared without feeling encumbered. More gear can slow you down, it can be difficult to carry, and make retrieving the right item even harder (although a proper gear organizer can help with this).

12345678910111213141516

A few tips to max out your carry would be to think of the gear you rely on most, then look for smaller versions you can use as backups. You can even pick up a duplicate item that has a slight variation to cover more bases. For example, your main EDC knife might have a straight edge, but your backup knife might be serrated.

What's Best? A Bit of Both

Both styles of EDC have their merits. And until you're looking at the extreme ends of either side, they're not exactly what I'd call mutually exclusive either. Ideally, your carry falls somewhere in between. It's got everything you need and nothing you don't. It'll take some personal experimentation to figure out what that is exactly, but chances are it'll end up closer to one style than the other.

So, what style of EDC do you prefer—minimalist or redundant? I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments below.

#minimalism #carry-smarter see all



Who Likes This (285)

276 others

Discussion (23 total)

Mine is in tiers. I have a backpack around me most of the time, so that can carry redundant and bulky items. On my person, it depends on what I'm doing, but a knife and flashlight and phone are a minimum. After that, a car key, tool keychain, wallet, maybe sunglasses. But that second group usually just live in the bag.
this is absolutely it. Keep 'essentials' close at hand, balancing weight and function. Back-ups and complements in the bag, with you but not always weighing you down.
Fantastic subject. I've been curating my EDC collection for over a year and what I've been focusing on is having the best "one" of everything that I need or most likely will need. I don't need to carry a dedicated knife, for example, but having one on a SAK and multi-tool is perfect. I always carry my essentials on me no matter if it's work or play, and I've planned it that way.

I spend days and weeks researching variations of the one item and the same amount of time choosing which one suits me for almost any situation. It has to fit my needs, my style and I have to love it. It's like drafting players in fantasy football for the best team. My EDC "team" consists of one: pen, wallet, key organizer, multi-tool, valet, hat, beanie, pencil, notebook, ear buds and carrier, hand lotion, lip balm, grid organizer, totem and more. Some of it has to be trial and error though. I bought and tried out 5 wallets before I found (and love) my current one.

Some items I do have more than one of. I currently have one hank but definitely will be getting more to rotate. I have 3 flashlights only because I showed my wife the 3 I was debating on and she surprised me with all 3 a couple of days later. I think bags (and pouches) in particular is an item you do need more than one of but I wouldn't call it redundancy. It's back to the "one" of everything philosophy. I have one dedicated for work, one 10L for hiking and hydration, one 25L cinch for bulk items or throw ins, one sling (although crappy) and currently have a 12L on pre-order as my everyday go out and play/weekend/vacation bag.

One of the reasons why I love seeing peoples EDC/pocket dumps is because they are basically curated collections of that persons style and personality. Because minimalism plays a huge part there was care and thought put into each item. They chose those brands, those materials, and those colors. They need an item with that functionality and that purpose. EDC collections are probably more revealing than dating profiles.

So what's better for EDC? I’d say whatever you need it to be.
Absolutely spot on! Been waiting for a piece on this subject. I keep a minimalist (micro) setup on me and my "2 is 1 and 1 is none" redundancy in my backpack. Whether you can bring it inside work or to keep in your car, that's what works for me. I used to carry everything but the kitchen sink, but I started to look like a homeboy with his pants saggin' down. I personally blame Nutnfancy, Cutlerylover, and Sooch on my bag being so damn heavy. Lmao
Gray man mimimal for me. I work in operating room so no need to carry thru out the day. Phone, gerber dime, keys. I have a Speck brand phone protector with built in CC holder holding 4 cards and a $20. Car has first responder fak. Weekend running gets all of the above plus my SW SHIELD 9mm and extra 10rd clip. I have a small kit for longer excursions, maxpedition hip pouch with 5C's and an addidas drawstring back sack to throw it all in if need the need to evac arises. Being a Corpsman with recon marines in my early days taught me minimalist approach long before the civilian world did. Semper Fi!
Redundancy is definitely my forte. 18650 powered primary light with a spare battery then a AAA powered back up since it's a common cell and readily available. Currently have a Thrunite TN12 (2016) and a Olight i3E EOS. I use my Gerber EAB when I'm not at work and have a Benchmade Griptillian 551 for more heavy duty cutting. Minimalist wallet seems like a given, though. Don't need an excess of cards so a wallet that's just large enough for the essentials seems best to me.
I have mine in several tiers. My car in there i have my get home bag, and wintertime only, stranded in the snow box. In my backpack i have my SAS survivalpack, a Caterpillar fannypack with the 5 C of survival and an one Tigris pouch as a tool kit.
And on my person a pocket organiser Cat Leo wirh several things like flashlight, Victorinox, first aid, powerbank, micro usb cable, pen. In my pockets knife, keychain edc, phone, and on my wrists watch and paracord bracelet. In my coat pocket wallet and selfdefence spray, and my survival box.
I'm a maximalist. I always feel it's better to "have and not need", rather than "need and not have".
Why not both?! Minimalistic Redundancy!
Pocket essentials and redundant items in a pack is definitley most ideal. I also keep an entire set of backups in my vehicle which I'm never too far from. Taste has a lot to do with it too, for some people. For example I don't use my knife terribly often right now but I can't stand the thought of needing to rummage through a multi tool, keychain, or bag, to have a cutting edge on hand. So, my primary knife with a pocket clip is a constant for me. Flashlights on the other hand, the one on my phone is satisfactory and easy to get to so a dedicated one isn't going in my pocket unless circumstances make it more necessary, so mine usually live in my bag and truck.Others feel they need a
A flashlight at their side at all times so they dedicate one to a pocket with a clip. This is fine too. If you're happy and reasonably prepared then you're edc-ing right.
I personally follow the redundant approach, especially since I could have most of my EDC fit comfortably in my backpack. I especially follow the redundant approach when I am dealing with EDC food, such as granola bars and ready-to-eat tuna, due to the fact that I am almost never alone and my friends often leech off of me.
Good conversation! I agree with several people below of doing the tier system:

In my pockets: keys, phone, wallet, writing utensil, pocket knife, rosary, handkerchief
Backpack: laptop, writing utensil pouch, notebook, book, flashlight, hand lotion, hand sanitizer, sleep mask, headphones, lens cleaner and cloth, tea bags and/or travel pourover coffee maker and filters
MOLLE pouches: 1) custom travel Mass kit; 2) "tech pouch" - USB drive, power stick, earbuds, audio adapters; 3) water bottle

I also have a sling/shoulder bag that I can attach my MOLLE pouches to as well - it depends what I'm doing that day (if I need the laptop or not).
Minimalist for me for sure. I carry a small split pea lighter, Classic SAK with built in light and pen, Mini Griffin Ti tool and ti whistle, all on my key chain... and that is it. Of course I have my phone, watch, and wallet as well. I have a go bag at home, a get home bag in my car, and an emergency pack in my office at work. I live and work in a City so this works perfect for me and has for a few years now.
I guess I fall in between. I want to carry it all but work regulations and the environment doesn't permit a whole ton of stuff. My desk contains my "back ups" for an urban environment, small first aid kit, and my vehicle contains more tools and heavier duty items like a full first aid kit, fire starting kit and etc. On my person I try to keep it to a min - pen, light, Gerber dime and field notes.
It depends on the situation. When I'm at work or traveling a long way out from home, I carry maxed out flashlight, multitool, knife etc. but when I'm at home or just around town where I'm not too far from help or resupply, I tend towards a more minimal carry. I've tried some paring down or getting rid of some tools but always feel unprepared. I guess that's part of a comfy carry though.
I'm a man of two worlds (like most), what I carry to and from work and what's on me at all other times. I always and I mean always have my SAK and a pocket knife (Kershaw/SpiderCo/Klecker), Burt's Beeswax and the phone (of course). It does not not get more minimal than that. However, I always and again I mean always carry a GHB (get home bag) as my organized EDC bag. I have so much that I want nearby in case of emergency and within that it's more or less 1 is none and 2 is 1. So I guess I'm either over weighted and mostly prepared or I'm at bare minimum 'cause the wife makes me go into TGIFriday's w/o the bag. At least I have my Victorinox.
6 more comments